As we come to the end of another year, I wanted to ask some of the prominent persons of the direct selling community what they see coming in 2017.
“What will be the most important issue, whether it be an opportunity or a threat, in the direct selling industry that will need a closer focus Next Year?” was the question.
You will read in this week’s article, their responses:
Oscar Cano Arias, Managing Director of Direct Selling Europe (DSE):
“Yet again, ethics will be a top issue in the year 2017. Due to the lack of serious and effective self-regulations in the US, the FTC is determined to react. In 2015, the FTC closes down Vemma accused of operating a pyramid scheme. Then, in July 2016, it adopts a Resolution against Herbalife that could have not been tougher: “Herbalife is going to start operating legitimately, making only truthful claims”… “Herbalife will have to restructure its business so that participants are rewarded for what they sell”… “Herbalife will have to compensate consumers […] as a result of unfair and deceptive practices”. 2017 will see new FTC Guidelines for the US direct selling industry, likely to include main points of the Resolution against Herbalife. Direct Selling Europe (DSE) welcomes the FTC move and invites the FTC to publish its new Guidelines the earliest possible. In the meanwhile, DSE continues working with all stakeholders to make sure that the interests and image of the well reputed and sustainable companies are well preserved.”
Jeff Babener, Legal Counsel at Babener and Associates:
“The thrust of the message of the October 2016 presentation of the FTC Chairwoman, Edith Ramirez was “more FTC regulation is coming… live with it”. On notice going forward: The FTC would reject a legal standard accepted by courts for 40 years, The Amway Safeguards Rule, and proposes guidance to “upend and reject” decades of industry practices that recognize full credit for personal use by distributors, track qualification volume based on wholesale movement of product, allow for monthly sales volume activity qualification based on distributor purchase volume and encourage and reward autoship programs that deliver predictable volumes to distributors. A surprise: The 2016 Presidential election results may usher in an anti-regulatory climate. Sponsor of a bi-partisan anti-pyramid bill to codify recognition of personal use purchases and establish legitimacy standards acceptable to the direct selling industry, is Rep. Marcia Blackburn, member of the Trump transition team and potential Cabinet member. To its surprise, this may be the year of opportunity for the industry to seek refuge from over-regulation, with model legislation that has already been adopted as law in more than a dozen states.”
Jacques Cosnefroy, General Secretary of the France Direct Selling Association (FVD):
“In a world in constant transformation, where the cultural revolutions are exempted from principles of belongings of the majorities, where the faith in the other one has become a variable of adaptation, where the inherent values of our personal construction are no longer considered as sources of reference, where the fear of the next day is a component of the everyday life, where the transparency is not anymore an option, the direct selling industry creates for each and every one a solid bedrock for the future, which could be threatened by a lack of control of our communication. Communication has become an asset and a threat for our companies! An asset because it offers this incomparable universal dimension which connects the people, and a threat because if uncontrolled it can convey unethical information that could severely damaged the image of the direct selling industry.”
Tamuna Gabilaia, Executive Director and Chief Operating Officer of The World Federation of Direct Selling Associations (WFDSA):
“2016 was a very exciting year for the industry. We saw sustained growth in all regions – global retail sales increased by 7.2% and the industry experienced 7.2% CAGR. We can see that people all over the world are increasingly interested in getting into business for themselves and we anticipate we will continue our growth pattern and will remain a vibrant industry bringing economic empowerment to people all around the globe. However, we still need to tell our story better. We need to align around messaging and a common narrative. There are widespread misperceptions and misunderstandings about direct selling. Explaining who we are and how our businesses work is an area we need to focus on. The WFDSA Messaging Guidebook developed under the WFDSA Advocacy Committee is a tool that will increase public understanding of direct selling and foster greater communication among member companies. Lastly, WFDSA World Congress XV “Rendezvous with the Future” which will be held in October 2017 will be an unforgettable event which will clearly demonstrate the key role our sector plays in the global economy.”
Brent Kugler, Partner at Scheef & Stone, LLP:
“The winds of change continue to grow stronger in the direct sales industry. Companies must be proactive in addressing changes that can now be seen as inevitable, if not mandatory, in light of recent FTC activity and comments from FTC Chairwoman Ramirez following FTC- Herbalife. The “wait and see what others do” approach is no longer a viable option in today’s regulatory climate. Companies must retool their compensation plans and reinvest in technology to track verifiable retail sales to non-distributor customers and calculate commissions and rank advancement based on those sales. Companies should also be wary of promoting “optional” high-priced enrollment bundles, as recent enforcement actions make clear that regulatory authorities are increasingly focused on the percentage of distributors who are unable to earn enough compensation to offset the cost of enrolling with a company.”
Alan Luce, Senior Managing Partner at Strategic Choice Partners:
“Rising to the challenge to provide world class access and service levels to end user customers and salesforce members will be the defining characteristic of successful direct selling companies in the future. Those companies that meet or exceed world class status in access and service will succeed. Those who do not raise their game will wither and fail as both customers and sales people choose to go elsewhere regardless of how good or unique their products and services may be.”
Nick Mallett, Director at Pan European Solutions:
“The Internet has reached the stage where established social media platforms are now less essential to new entrants to networking businesses. There will be increasing instances of ‘private’ networking portals, worldwide. These represent a competitive threat to established network marketing businesses. We see a serious risk from the spread of such platforms in the regulatory sense of their being somehow above the law, through operating in the ‘virtual world’. The viral spread of such businesses is such that they are subject to the laws of the many jurisdictions in which they operate. On the one hand, they may be able to carry on business in multiple jurisdictions despite being closed down in one or more where their operation contravenes local legislation; on the other, a regulatory challenge in one jurisdiction might just cause them to close down altogether. In the meantime, they may have given network marketing such a bad name – perhaps worldwide – that the various regulators introduce a more restrictive regime of control such as to restrict the previously legitimate activities of our established network business clients. We must be vigilant on behalf of the legitimate industry.”
Katarina Molin, Executive Director of The European Direct Selling Association (Seldia):
“In 2017, we expect the positive growth for direct selling in the European region to continue, which shows that it continues to be a vibrant retail sector and enjoys high consumer trust. From a policy perspective, Seldia will continue its close dialogue with European policymakers on the EU consumer policy. It will be crucial to focus on the proper implementation and enforcement of existing EU legislation, an area that needs more attention in the future. Addressing issues such as non-tariff barriers as well as how to effectively put a stop to the practices of rogue traders must be prioritized. It is also time to step up our efforts to communicate better and more transparently on how the sector works, on what the channel is – and is not. We must also explain that it is not outdated channel of distribution, but on the contrary – very receptive to innovations and technological development. In terms of communication, it will be important to engage in a constructive discussion about segmentation of the people involved in direct selling, to keep a continued focus on ethics, and to collect independently verified data to share externally.”
Gillian Stapleton, Executive Director of the Australia Direct Selling Association (DSA):
“The Entrepreneurial Consumer is both an opportunity and threat. Great service has long defined direct-selling: establishing great rapport in-home, the personal delivery of products and follow up every season. Will that define the industry in the next 5 years? Direct-selling faces the biggest challenge in service it has ever experienced. Next day delivery, packaged in tissue paper, a hand -written note signed by the packer, establishes a good relationship for me with that company. An offer to exchange the goods or have three alternatives shipped at no cost to me and send back what I don’t want. That cements it. I am the Entrepreneurial Consumer and I could be your consultant. Will your company attract me?”
Bobbie Wasserman, Managing Director of Wave2 Alliances:
“The FTC is now distinguishing between Distributors, personal consumption and customer purchases. Direct selling companies can harness this opportunity to engage and attract more customers – helping build each company’s credibility for its own brand and contribute to enhancing the industry’s credibility. Public relation campaigns focusing on executives’ leadership, premium products/services and entrepreneurial successes can provide a corporate narrative and business tools for Distributors. In the future, the industry can argue the semantics of purchase behavior via legal battles. However, now is the time to impact decisions being made in the ‘court of public opinion’ – those decisions are often made swiftly and without access to an appeal.”